Saturn V by space observer

[Space observer]

I made the saturn V, to test my skills at building. I want someone rate it

 

[TtTOtW]

I tell you what. Ill train you, and I'll start with helping you get your Sat V right. Deal?

 

[Space observer]

I tell you what. Ill train you, and I'll start with helping you get your Sat V right. Deal?

No, I didnt mean i need train. I just want someone rate it.

 

[TtTOtW]

Well, ok it's your choice. You didn't ask but I did offer. It still stands.

I rate your rocket 6/10. Scale is off but it is at least easily recognizable. Also lost points for 2nd stage engine spam, as well as them being the completely wrong engine for a J2 replica. LEM is zero effort.

 

[オリオン312]

Well, ok it's your choice. You didn't ask but I did offer. It still stands.

I rate your rocket 6/10. Scale is off but it is at least easily recognizable. Also lost points for 2nd stage engine spam, as well as them being the completely wrong engine for a J2 replica. LEM is zero effort.

id say about a 4/10 too slim

 

[Marmilo]

3/10...
But I've seen much worse
Try to use the engines that correspond to those used in the real rocket. J-2 is basically a frontier. Both are large vacuum engines with a blue plume. The Saturn V is 10m in diameter, 111m tall. You need to clip or bp edit parts to achieve such wide fuel tanks. The CSM is 4m in diameter, your's is 2m. It looks nothing alike the real one. The lander is garbage. No offense, but I think you can agree. I see NO similarity between the real one and your rectangular block of fuel. You can make a good Saturn V without bp editing, but it just won't be as good as one using it. It is recognizable though. And even if you don't care about 1:1 scale, at least keep proportions in mind. The LM is smaller than the CSM. You can make a good Saturn V, but it's not something you can do in an hour. In order to make a good replica you usually spend more time researching the proper dimensions/engines than building the rocket itself.
Check out these sites, they can help you greatly.
https://m.wikipedia.com
https://astronautix.com

Oh, also bonus credit for using windows 7 <3

 

[TtTOtW]

Yeah lol, XP would have got him 10 extra bonus points XD

 

[Mars Pathfinder]

Yeah lol, XP would have got him 10 extra bonus points XD

How bout the vista? XD

 

[Marmilo]

windows 11 is negative points btw

 

[NeoTheProto]

windows 11 is negative points btw

That ain’t windows 11 that’s like Windows XP or vista

 

[Marmilo]

That ain’t windows 11 that’s like Windows XP or vista

ikr, i said it's windows 7
i said before that he gets extra respect for using windows 7, then i expressed my dislike for windows 11

 

[The epic chicken]

ikr, i said it's windows 7
i said before that he gets extra respect for using windows 7, then i expressed my dislike for windows 11

Why'd they have to move the start into the middle, years of knowing that the start will be at the bottom left corner is hard to unlearn

 

[Marmilo]

Why'd they have to move the start into the middle, years of knowing that the start will be at the bottom left corner is hard to unlearn

windows 11 is just so messed up

 

[The epic chicken]

windows 11 is just so messed up

Yea

 

[オリオン312]

windows 11 is just so messed up

btw whats wrong with windows 11?

 

[The epic chicken]

btw whats wrong with windows 11?

Nothing really, I have it on my old computer, but its just confusing as hell because everything has been moved into a different place, and things that could be done in one click on 10 needs multiple clicks in 11

 

[オリオン312]

Nothing really, I have it on my old computer, but its just confusing as hell because everything has been moved into a different place, and things that could be done in one click on 10 needs multiple clicks in 11

oh ok