SP'entry 1:1 replica

Blazer Ayanami

Space Shuttle enthusiast // Retired Admin
Registered
Forum Legend
#28
1. Your boosters (first stage) are 24.5 m tall, the real ones are 25 m.
2. Your core stage (aka second stage) Is 17.5 m tall. The one on the GSLV mk.3 is 21.39 m tall (which is closer to 21.5).
3. That weird structure on the GSLV's upper stage seems nowhere like yours.
4. As SFS Abhishek pointed out. Your fairing seems too short.
 

Space pilot

ET phone home
Floater
Man on the Moon
Registered
#29
1. Your boosters (first stage) are 24.5 m tall, the real ones are 25 m.
2. Your core stage (aka second stage) Is 17.5 m tall. The one on the GSLV mk.3 is 21.39 m tall (which is closer to 21.5).
3. That weird structure on the GSLV's upper stage seems nowhere like yours.
4. As SFS Abhishek pointed out. Your fairing seems too short.
maxresdefault.jpg
 

Space pilot

ET phone home
Floater
Man on the Moon
Registered
#30
1. Your boosters (first stage) are 24.5 m tall, the real ones are 25 m.
2. Your core stage (aka second stage) Is 17.5 m tall. The one on the GSLV mk.3 is 21.39 m tall (which is closer to 21.5).
3. That weird structure on the GSLV's upper stage seems nowhere like yours.
4. As SFS Abhishek pointed out. Your fairing seems too short.
Screenshot_2021-07-08-19-33-21-374_com.StefMorojna.SpaceflightSimulator.jpg
 
Last edited:

Nagini

ssssnake // has nothing against SpaceX replicas
TEAM HAWK
Swingin' on a Star
Atlas
Deja Vu
Fly me to the Moon
Under Pressure
Copycat
Registered
#31
You still didn’t change the BOOSTAHZ
 

Nagini

ssssnake // has nothing against SpaceX replicas
TEAM HAWK
Swingin' on a Star
Atlas
Deja Vu
Fly me to the Moon
Under Pressure
Copycat
Registered
#34
The fairing probably covers some of the upper stage
 

Blazer Ayanami

Space Shuttle enthusiast // Retired Admin
Registered
Forum Legend
#36
Space Pilot, you still haven't fixed anything of what I said:
1. Your boosters (first stage) are 24.5 m tall, the real ones are 25 m.
2. Your core stage (aka second stage) Is 17.5 m tall. The one on the GSLV mk.3 is 21.39 m tall (which is closer to 21.5).
3. That weird structure on the GSLV's upper stage seems nowhere like yours.
4. As SFS Abhishek pointed out. Your fairing seems too short.
Anything.

The measures are still wrong and you made the upper stage even less like the real one.
 

Pink

(Mooncrasher)
Staff member
Team Valiant
Discord Staff
Voyager Quest
Man on the Moon
Forum Legend
#37
Blazer gave you the proper measurements, it will never be accepted until they match to the nearest 0.5m. So why keep posting wrong size rocket and wasting his time?
 

Space pilot

ET phone home
Floater
Man on the Moon
Registered
#38
IMG_20210708_233808.jpg

Screenshot_2021-07-08-23-50-47-756_com.StefMorojna.SpaceflightSimulator.jpg

I know for are also tired but I'm also trying to make replica from three days
 
Last edited:

Pink

(Mooncrasher)
Staff member
Team Valiant
Discord Staff
Voyager Quest
Man on the Moon
Forum Legend
#39
1. Your boosters are slightly less than 25m tall, the ones on the GSLV mk.3 are 25 m tall. OK!

2. Your core stage is 23 m tall. The one on the GSLV mk.3 is 21.39 m tall (which you can round to 21.5). Not ok!

3. Your upper stage is 12 m tall, the one on the GSLV mk.3 is 13.5 m tall. Not ok!

4. The entire rocket is 43m high, it should be 43.5m high. Not ok!

All diameters seem ok.
You can ask for advice, but don't just post the rocket again for us to check if 2, 3 and 4 are NOT FIXED.

if you're tired, just take a break for as long as you want.
 

Pink

(Mooncrasher)
Staff member
Team Valiant
Discord Staff
Voyager Quest
Man on the Moon
Forum Legend
#41
Nope, not as far as I can tell.
 

Pink

(Mooncrasher)
Staff member
Team Valiant
Discord Staff
Voyager Quest
Man on the Moon
Forum Legend
#43
Looks better now, the dimensions do indeed match up.
Btw, you do realise that rocket won't even get off the ground with a payload? It needs moar engines in order to be able to deliver a satellite to orbit.

Maybe do some small amount of engine stretching, that's allowed for replica challenge.
 

Nagini

ssssnake // has nothing against SpaceX replicas
TEAM HAWK
Swingin' on a Star
Atlas
Deja Vu
Fly me to the Moon
Under Pressure
Copycat
Registered
#47
Nah you can still use this as a team Hawk entry
 

Pink

(Mooncrasher)
Staff member
Team Valiant
Discord Staff
Voyager Quest
Man on the Moon
Forum Legend
#48
Or for team frontier even, since it was already submitted, as the RAQ says.
 

Space pilot

ET phone home
Floater
Man on the Moon
Registered
#50
Okok
But after completing team frontier
I wanted to do Mercury mission first
Count this mission after Mercury missionnow I will read raq